Players / Player profile
CLE · 1B

Kyle Manzardo

Age 26 B/T L/R 5′11″, 205 lb USA MLB debut 2024
40-man
  • Cleveland’s roster as it stands starts at DH · 427 PA · 0.5 WAR in the role
  • Trade read Available at a price: CLE 49% playoff odds; control through 2030.
xwOBA .305 wOBA .310
2026 fWAR −0.2
Projected 2027 WAR 0.5 at 431 PA · 0.5 in his 2027 role

Hitting · 2026 percentiles

vs. MLB hitters with 300+ PA · 354 PA

xwOBA .305 xwOBA: .305, 30th percentile
Swing decisions −0.04 Swing decisions: −0.04, 45th percentile
Contact value −0.39 Contact value: −0.39, 32nd percentile
Bat speed 69.8 Bat speed: 69.8, 21st percentile
Squared-up / swing 22% Squared-up / swing: 22%, 40th percentile
Blasts / swing 4% Blasts / swing: 4%, 9th percentile
EV90 101.6 EV90: 101.6, 18th percentile
Barrel % 12.1% Barrel %: 12.1%, 79th percentile
Chase % 30.8% Chase %: 30.8%, 42nd percentile
Zone contact 79.8% Zone contact: 79.8%, 18th percentile
Strikeout % 31.9% Strikeout %: 31.9%, 4th percentile
Walk % 9.9% Walk %: 9.9%, 64th percentile

Platoon splits · swing path

By pitcher handedness

vsPAwOBAxwOBAK%BB%ChaseDecisionsContact
LHP73.307.33527%14%35%−0.63+1.42
RHP281.310.29733%9%30%+0.09−0.84
Attack angle
17.9° (50% in 5–20°)
Attack direction
−0.2°
Swing length
7.4 ft
Fast-swing rate
6%
Pull-air %
24.2%
Hard-hit %
41.2%
Slash · wRC+
.215/.306/.378 · 94

Zone map · 2026

Where he does damage, and where to pitch him

+0.6−1.6+1.2+0.6+0.5−0.2+0.3−2.3+1.9+1.0−0.8−0.1−0.1−4.0−0.7+1.0+2.8+0.70.0−3.1−1.5−1.1−0.7+0.8−1.4LHB

Does the most damage down and away (+2.8 vs. league per 100; 1.3 standard errors on 64 pitches, inside the noise for the best of nine cells).

Weakest middle-in (−4.0), but only 1.8 standard errors from average on 60 pitches: no in-zone spot to attack yet.

Runs per 100 pitches vs. an average LHB: better · worse. Catcher’s view · 1,314 pitches · faded cells are within one standard error of average. A spot is called only when it is farther from average than the best or worst of nine average cells gets 95% of the time (set from the league’s own pitches: about 3 standard errors above, 2 below).

Most similar hitters

Swings like Manzardo: bat path, contact quality and approach

SimilarityPlayerxwOBA’26 WAR’27 proj2027
57Connor Norby COL · ’00.3100.60.6Pre-arb
56Kerry Carpenter DET · ’97.298−0.60.7Arb
55Andrew Benintendi CWS · ’94.310−0.1−0.4Signed $15.1M
50Miguel Amaya CHC · ’99.2991.41.3Arb
46Zach Neto LAA · ’01.3173.93.4Arb

Nearest neighbours on bat speed, swing length, attack angle, squared-up and blast rates, EV90, barrels, pull-air, chase, zone contact, K% and BB%. 2026 regulars only.

Fielding

2027 rating at every position he can play · OAA by position · range by direction · tools. Same engine as the Fielding Lab and the Winter Plan.

2027 rating by position · best fit first, on the total with the position’s worth
1B −4.2 −16.7
Outs Above Average by position
SeasonPosOAARangeArm, DPRunsBatters
20261B−5−4+1.7−2.32,597
20251B−3−2−3.1−5.11,942
20241B000.00.0110

Runs = range plus his arm and double-play runs spread over his positions by outs (Fielding Run Value, from 2023): what the rating counts.

Range by direction (OAA at 1B)
2025 · 1B2026 · 1B In (charging) −2−1Back −1−1Toward 3B line −1−4Toward 1B line +1+2vs. RHH −2−6vs. LHH −10

At 1B in 2026, the biggest loss came toward 3B line (−4 outs): a coaching target.

Tools (percentile; arm among 1Bs)
Arm at 1B 71.4 mph · 21st
Sprint speed 25.4 ft/s · 10th
Zone rating (Keystone expected outs)
SeasonZoneBallsOuts vs. exp.
20261B170+3.3
20251B102+0.2

The zone rating counts every ball hit to his part of the field while he played there, his club’s positioning included; Savant OAA uses his actual starting spot and is the better individual grade. They agree best in the outfield. See the model card.

Compare in the Fielding Lab →

Contract & projection

Club control (RosterResource) · Keystone projected WAR

2027 0.5 WAR Pre-arb $780K*
2028 0.5 WAR Arbitration $1.5M*
2029 0.4 WAR Arbitration $2.4M*
2030 0.2 WAR Arbitration $2.8M*

* projected arbitration or minimum salary. Contract Studio →

Minor leagues

MLB Stats API · public box-score data

SeasonLevelLevelTeamAgeGPA / IPPA / IP ·Line
2026AAAAAAColumbus Clippers2537165 PA 165 PA · .283/.352/.469 · 5 HR · 24.2% K · 10.3% BB

ABS challenges · 2026

Baseball Savant

As batter 40% 2/5 won · −0.2 runs
Keystone is an independent portfolio project. It is not affiliated with Major League Baseball or any club. Data: MLB Stats API, Baseball Savant, FanGraphs. Used under their terms for individual, non-commercial use.